Using AI To Support Recombination


Patented innovations line shelves as shown in the patent library above, and over the years I’ve written a number of times about the increasingly recombinative nature of innovation.  This posits that new innovations are often a combination of existing innovations rather than truly novel ones.  A paper from a few years ago found that roughly 40% of all patents were of this nature, with the number growing in recent times.

A recent paper from researchers at Carnegie Mellon University and the Hebrew University of Jerusalem highlights an AI driven approach to mine databases of patents and research papers for ideas that can be recombined into solutions for new problems.

Analogous Innovation

Central to the approach was an attempt to find analogies that connect seemingly disparate methods and problems.  They used crowdsourcing to understand how people form analogies, before using this to train a deep learning algorithm to then mine the intellectual databases for potential innovations.

“After decades of attempts, this is the first time that anyone has gained traction computationally on the analogy problem at scale,” the authors say.

Once you can search for analogies, you can really crank up the speed of innovation, If you can accelerate the rate of innovation, that solves a lot of other problems downstream.”

Suffice to say, discovering analogies is not the easiest thing for a computer to do as it’s often one of those things we humans do without always understanding how we do it.  Previous attempts at automating the job first required a handcrafted data structure to be created, which is incredibly time consuming and therefore not at all scalable.

Into the Crowd

The team turned to Mechanical Turk to recruit a number of volunteers to look for analogous products via the product innovation website Quirky.  They did this by looking for a range of products with similar purposes or means of doing their job.

Each participant was told to explain how they came to their conclusions.  For instance, they might describe a product in terms of both its purpose and its mechanism.  This helps to provide connectors that can be used in creating the analogies.

These insights were then fed into the algorithm, before it was set loose on an additional dataset of product descriptions.  The researchers tasked the algorithm with coming up some analogies of its own.  Interestingly, it proved rather good at the task, and went beyond mere surface similarities to discover similarities between seemingly very different products.  Indeed, when these were tested, the new product suggestions were rated as the most innovative ideas.

The team believe that the approach could easily be scaled up to be used as part of the innovation process by allowing organizations to find previously hidden connections between patents or research papers.  With both datasets enormous and growing at a tremendous rate, it’s a problem that well suits autonomous methods, so it will be interesting to see what comes next for the team and their system.

Wait! Before you go…

Choose how you want the latest innovation content delivered to you:

Adi-Gaskell-150x150Adi Gaskell tells us: “I am a free range human who believes that the future already exists if we know where to look. From the bustling Knowledge Quarter in London, it is my mission in life to hunt down those things and bring them to a wider audience, with my posts here focusing particularly on the latest research on innovation and change.” Follow Adi @adigaskell

Adi Gaskell




How eco-friendly is the production of bikes and e-bikes in comparison to cars?

By Hubert Day | April 27, 2022

Photo by Himiway Bikes on Unsplash We are all well aware of the benefits cycling can have, both on our…

Read More

Three things young people should know about apprenticeships

By Hubert Day | March 10, 2022

Photo by Mars on Unsplash Times are changing for young people after they leave school. Once, no one went to…

Read More

Leave a Comment