Finding Your Silver Bullet in an Apple Pie

Finding Your Silver Bullet in an Apple Pie

A parable…

Once upon a time, a man was served a dessert of home baked apple pie at a dinner hosted by his neighbor. The man had never before tasted such a perfect pie crust. “What is your secret?” he asked his host. “You are welcome to my recipe,” replied the neighbor. “There’s no secret. It’s all right there in black and white.”

Once home, the man enthusiastically planned his first apple pie. To his surprise, the new recipe contained most of the same ingredients as his own pie crust, and the procedure was quite similar. Nevertheless, he followed the recipe for the crust to the letter. Unfortunately, his first attempt yielded a crust that was inferior compared to that of his neighbor’s. He decided to pay his neighbor a visit to speak with him.

During their discussion, the neighbor revealed a number of techniques not in the printed recipe, such as the kind of pie plate used. With renewed excitement, the man made his second attempt. This crust was better, yet the result was still not as good as the neighbor’s. A return visit seemed in order.

“May I watch you prepare your crust?” the man asked his neighbor. “Of course,” the neighbor replied. As he watched the crust being prepared, the man noted several nuances that were neither in the recipe nor revealed on his previous visit. Curious, he inquired of his neighbor the reasoning behind these nuances. Convinced that he now knew all of the secrets, the man made his third pie.

The result of this third attempt was much closer, but still not satisfactory. The man decided to invite his neighbor over to watch him prepare the crust. When the neighbor arrived, he immediately noted the difference in temperature and humidity of the kitchen, as well as the difference in brands of ingredients, types of utensils, dishes, and oven being used.

“This changes everything!” the neighbor exclaimed. “It would take me many attempts in this very kitchen to perfect the crust. And it will take you many times as well. You have the right recipe, but you must search for your own secrets.”

Moral of the story: that [insert unicorn de jour name here] best practice you just read about worked well for the company that created it, and it appears to be the silver bullet to solve all your own problems — your recipe for success. But my bet is it won’t work in any way that produces a sustainable edge for your company.

Search for your own secrets.

Get a Change Planning Toolkit Facilitated Project Kickoff

Wait! Before you go…

Choose how you want the latest innovation content delivered to you:

Matthew E MayMatthew E. May is the author, most recently, of Winning the Brain Game: Fixing the 7 Fatal Flaws of Thinking.

Posted in

Matthew E May




Our Annual Trends Report: Boosting the Possibilities for 2021

By Shawn Nason | February 25, 2021

  I still remember the day we got the email telling us that the in-person version of the 2021 Consumer…

Read More

Controlling the controllables

By Janet Sernack | February 22, 2021

A recent article by McKinsey and Co “COVID-19: Implications for business”  describes a paradoxical dilemma for managers: the need to process both the…

Read More

Leave a Comment