Business Models Versus Strategy Part 2
If You Need to Think About Business Models, You Don’t Have a Strategy in the First Place.
by Idris Mootee
Silicon Valley is probably the only place in the world where people puts lots of money into companies (technologies) before figuring how does it make money. And that’s where the term “business model” came from. I heard recently that someone is stupid enough to think about developing an application to design business models for use in iPad. That’s really a joke, if business is that simple. I believe it will come with many templates, if you need to use them to design your business model, it is like using Microsoft PowerPoint with built-in templates to create your presentations. Bad idea.
For those who are still confused about business model, let me provide you with more clarifications. Are business models and business strategy really just the same thing? Business models were first popularized when there were a lot of technologies investments in the early 90’s with no idea of how to create value or how to make money. So it is essentially a company with a half-baked strategy, meaning they have a customer value proposition, but don’t know who they are selling to and who they are competing with, attracted lots of users but cannot charge them for the services and so have no idea of how to make money. Or another way to look at it, they have either assets (content), audiences (eyeballs) or members (communities) and need to figure out a way to monetize them. I think monetization strategy is a better word than business models.
If you need to look for a business model, it means you don’t have a sound strategy in the first place. It is like firing a missile first and then go looking for a target, but your fuel is limited. If you are Facebook, then it is a different story, that’s really an exception. You have almost unlimited fuel circling the earth.
Business model should have a narrow focus on how the company can make money and put emphasis on pricing strategy, strategic partnerships and channel choice. All of these decisions are around top line impact with a goal to optimize revenue or sometimes survive an early phase of a business. It is a creative design of how a company makes money through a variety of revenue streams. Business strategy deals with much broader and deeper issues including competitive differentiation, capital structure, cost structure and asset utilization, etc.
I hope this helps to clarify this. A key takeaway for you, don’t rely on business model design to save your business, look at the overall business strategy. That’s should be the main focus. Business models are just another hyped up thing. A case in point – the media business is facing daunting challenge and many believe that it’s unquestionably the business model is not working. One example is struggling to find how to generate revenues online that are comparable to what their traditional businesses yield or how new digital realms generate the revenue it will take to support high quality journalism. This is not a business model problem, it is a strategy problem. Media needs new strategic thinking, not playing around with its business models.
Idris Mootee is the CEO of idea couture, a strategic innovation and experience design firm. He is the author of four books, tens of published articles, and a frequent speaker at business conferences and executive retreats.
NEVER MISS ANOTHER NEWSLETTER!
Leo Tilman and Charles Jacoby write in their book Agility: How to Navigate the Unknown and Seize Opportunity in a…Read More